Stone vs. Style: When to Say Goodbye to Interior Stonework
March 20, 2025
Natural stone has its moments. It’s timeless, textural, and grounding. Generally, we love it—until we don't. Sometimes, it can weigh down a space (literally and stylistically), making a room feel more medieval fortress than homey retreat.
In our Modern Meadow Remodel, we faced this exact dilemma. The home featured heavy stone fireplaces in the great room, stairwell, and lower family room. Normally, we love incorporating natural materials into a design, finding ways to honor a home’s original character. But in this case? The stone had to go.
Why We Said Goodbye to the Stone
1. It Wasn’t the Client’s Vibe
First and foremost—our client wasn’t feeling it. No matter how well something is designed, if it doesn’t align with the homeowner’s vision, it’s got to go. A successful remodel isn’t just about making a space look good; it’s about making it feel right for the people who live there.
2. The Stairwell Layout Had to Change
Sometimes, function dictates form. In reworking the layout of the stairwell, the existing stone structure became an obstacle. Since we were already making major structural adjustments, removing the stone was a natural decision.
3. It Was Bulky (And We Mean, Really Bulky)
The stone wasn’t just a feature—it was a presence. It took up valuable floorspace in both the great room and the lower family room, making these key gathering areas feel cramped. Replacing it with something more modern and streamlined opened up the rooms, creating a lighter, more inviting atmosphere.
4. The Look Was Outdated
While stone can be stunning in the right setting, this particular application felt less charming European villa and more dark and dated. Our goal was to bring in a fresher, more updated aesthetic that aligned with the rest of the remodel.
What We Replaced It With
Rather than simply swapping one material for another, we focused on lightening the visual weight of the space. Clean lines, refined textures, and a modern approach brought warmth and depth without the bulk. Think sleek finishes, updated architectural details, and a focus on openness—a major glow-up from the original fortress-like feel.
- In the great room, the heavy stone was replaced with warm wood paneling and a stunning graphite marble fireplace, creating a refined, modern focal point.
- In the lower family room, we swapped the bulky stone for custom built-in cabinetry, giving our client’s family more storage, a cleaner aesthetic, and a much-improved TV viewing experience.
By trading excess weight for thoughtful, intentional design, we transformed these spaces from overwhelming to effortlessly functional and beautiful.
When to Keep the Stone vs. When to Let It Go
Still debating whether to part ways with the heavy stone in your home? Here are some key considerations:
✅ Keep it if...
- It adds character that enhances the overall design.
- It’s balanced by other modern elements to prevent heaviness.
- It fits your personal style and works with your vision.
❌ Lose it if...
- It’s consuming valuable floorspace.
- It makes the space feel closed off or visually heavy.
- The style feels outdated and doesn’t align with your aesthetic.
At the end of the day, good design is about balance—knowing when to preserve and when to edit. In the Modern Meadow Remodel, saying goodbye to the heavy stone was the right call. The result? A space that feels fresh, open, and perfectly suited to our client’s style.
If you haven't seen the full home tour (seriously, what are you even doing?!) make sure you check it out on our YouTube and click the video below! ↓
